Skip to content

Debt cost comparison tool

Debt Consolidation Calculator

Compare keeping your current debts with replacing them through one fixed-rate loan. See payments, interest, fees, payoff timing, and the APR where consolidation breaks even.

Debt and loan details

Results reflect the last successful comparison. Editing fields does not change them until you compare again.

Current debts

Enter 1–20 balances that the new loan would repay in full. Amounts are in USD.

Current payment plan

Current debts use Debt Avalanche and preserve the initial payment budget as debts close.

Consolidation loan
Fees

Fee handling

Repayment plan

The new loan always receives at least its contractual payment.

Default debt consolidation comparison is displayed.

Comparison status

Lower estimated total cost

A mathematical comparison of the submitted scenarios, not a credit or lender recommendation.

Debt consolidation results

Based on the most recently submitted values; fees are paid upfront.

Estimated total cost difference

$4,971.29 estimated savings

Current debts payoff time

3 years 8 months

Consolidation payoff time

3 years

Months saved or added

8 months saved

Current monthly debt budget

$790.00

Consolidation monthly payment

$806.56

Monthly payment change

$16.56 monthly increase

Current-plan total interest

$9,757.53

Consolidation interest

$4,036.24

Origination and closing fees

$750.00

Break-even consolidation APR

21.22%

Original consolidation principal

$25,000.00

Total consolidation amount paid

$29,036.24

Consolidation payoff date

August 31, 2029

Current debts payoff date

April 30, 2030

Cost breakdown

Keep current debts

Original principal

$25,000.00

Total interest

$9,757.53

Total payments

$34,757.53

Monthly debt budget

$790.00

Payoff time

3 years 8 months

Payoff date

April 30, 2030

Consolidate debts

Debt amount refinanced

$25,000.00

Financed fees

$0.00

Original loan principal

$25,000.00

Upfront fees

$750.00

Total interest

$4,036.24

Total loan payments

$29,036.24

Total out-of-pocket

$29,786.24

Planned monthly payment

$806.56

Payoff time

3 years

Payoff date

August 31, 2029

Interest difference

$5,721.29

Fee impact

$750.00

Total cost difference

$4,971.29 estimated savings

Term difference

8 months saved

Monthly cash-flow difference

$16.56 monthly increase

Current-debt payoff order

Ordered by the actual month and allocation sequence in which balances close.

#DebtStarting balanceAPRPayoff monthPayoff dateInterest paidTotal paid
1Personal loan$12,000.0011.99%Aug 2029August 31, 2029$2,336.02$14,336.02
2Credit card$8,000.0024.99%Mar 2030March 31, 2030$5,102.55$13,102.55
3Mastercard$5,000.0019.99%Apr 2030April 30, 2030$2,318.96$7,318.96

Monthly comparison schedule

Expand a month to audit the active current debts. Completed scenarios remain at zero while the other continues.

MonthCurrent beginningCurrent interestCurrent paymentCurrent endingLoan beginningLoan interestLoan paymentLoan endingBalance differenceCumulative cost difference
$25,000.00$369.79$790.00$24,579.79$25,000.00$208.13$806.56$24,401.56$178.23-$588.33
$24,579.79$364.35$790.00$24,154.14$24,401.56$203.14$806.56$23,798.14$356.00-$427.12
$24,154.14$358.84$790.00$23,722.98$23,798.14$198.12$806.56$23,189.70$533.28-$266.41
$23,722.98$353.24$790.00$23,286.22$23,189.70$193.05$806.56$22,576.19$710.03-$106.22
$23,286.22$347.56$790.00$22,843.78$22,576.19$187.95$806.56$21,957.58$886.21$53.40
$22,843.78$341.80$790.00$22,395.59$21,957.58$182.80$806.56$21,333.81$1,061.78$212.40
$22,395.59$335.96$790.00$21,941.55$21,333.81$177.60$806.56$20,704.85$1,236.70$370.76
$21,941.55$330.03$790.00$21,481.58$20,704.85$172.37$806.56$20,070.66$1,410.92$528.42
$21,481.58$324.02$790.00$21,015.60$20,070.66$167.09$806.56$19,431.18$1,584.42$685.36
$21,015.60$317.92$790.00$20,543.52$19,431.18$161.76$806.56$18,786.39$1,757.13$841.51
$20,543.52$311.73$790.00$20,065.25$18,786.39$156.40$806.56$18,136.22$1,929.03$996.84
$20,065.25$305.45$790.00$19,580.70$18,136.22$150.98$806.56$17,480.64$2,100.05$1,151.31

Yearly comparison

Aggregated directly from monthly schedules. Upfront fees are shown separately in the first period.

PeriodCurrent startCurrent paymentsCurrent interestCurrent endLoan startLoan paymentsLoan interestLoan endUpfront feesCumulative cost difference
Sep–Dec 2026$25,000.00$3,160.00$1,446.22$23,286.22$25,000.00$3,226.25$802.44$22,576.19$750.00-$106.22
2027$23,286.22$9,480.00$3,771.60$17,577.82$22,576.19$9,678.75$1,905.85$14,803.30$0.00$1,759.53
2028$17,577.82$9,480.00$2,796.16$10,893.99$14,803.30$9,678.75$1,092.78$6,217.33$0.00$3,462.91
2029$10,893.99$9,480.00$1,602.26$3,016.25$6,217.33$6,452.50$235.17$0.00$0.00$4,830.01
Jan–Apr 2030$3,016.25$3,157.53$141.28$0.00$0.00$0.00$0.00$0.00$0.00$4,971.29
Remaining balance comparison

Solid and dashed lines compare balances; labeled vertical markers show each payoff month.

Current debts reach $0.00 in month 44; the consolidation loan reaches $0.00 in month 36.

Cumulative borrowing cost

Current interest is solid. Consolidation interest plus all fees is dashed; fees enter at the start and are not counted twice.

At payoff: $9,757.53 current-plan interest versus $4,786.24 consolidation borrowing cost.

How the Debt Consolidation Calculator works

Comparing two complete scenarios

The current plan carries every balance forward with monthly interest and Debt Avalanche payments. The consolidation plan repays all entered debts at the start and amortizes one new loan. Total out-of-pocket amounts, payoff timing, and monthly cash flow are compared from the same first payment month.

Weighted average APR is not enough

A balance-weighted APR can summarize current rates, but it cannot model changing balances, minimum-payment rollover, a new term, origination costs, financed fees, or early payoff. The calculator simulates each month because those details determine actual estimated cost.

Debt Avalanche and rollover

Each active current debt receives its minimum first. Remaining money goes to the highest APR, with smaller balance and original order as tie-breaks. The initial total debt budget stays fixed, so a paid-off debt’s minimum moves to the next target immediately.

Contractual loan payment

The new loan uses the standard fixed-payment amortization equation with nominal APR divided by 12. At 0% APR, principal is divided by the term. Extra payments begin in month one, final payments are limited to the amount due, and payoff may occur early.

Upfront fees vs financed fees

Upfront fees are outside the loan balance and never accrue loan interest. Financed fees increase original principal and therefore interest. In either case, origination fees are calculated from the refinanced debt amount and included only once in total out-of-pocket cost.

Why a smaller payment may cost more

Reducing the payment often lengthens repayment. More months of interest plus fees can outweigh a lower APR, so monthly cash-flow change and total cost difference are shown separately. A lower payment is a tradeoff, not an automatic improvement.

Loan term and total interest

A longer contractual term usually lowers the required payment but creates more opportunities for interest to accrue. Keeping the current debt budget or adding extra can shorten the modeled payoff, while the submitted term still determines the contractual minimum.

Understanding break-even APR

Break-even APR is found by repeatedly running the same consolidation simulation between 0% and 100%. It holds term, fees, fee handling, repayment plan, and extra payment constant and finds the highest rate that does not exceed the completed current plan’s total out-of-pocket cost.

Using schedules and charts

The monthly schedule lets you inspect aggregate balances and expand current-debt allocations. Yearly rows come directly from those months. The charts show remaining balances and cumulative borrowing costs, including fees at the start of consolidation.

Why a real offer may differ

Lenders may use daily interest, deduct fees from proceeds, apply different payment rules, or change terms after underwriting. Credit history and income can affect approval and pricing. Use the result to compare a consistent estimate with an actual disclosure, not as a guaranteed quote.

Model limitations

The model assumes fixed APRs, monthly accrual, no new purchases, no late payments, and full consolidation. It excludes promotional rates, penalties, taxes, lender-specific rounding, variable rates, credit limits, and behavioral changes. Current-debt projections stop after 1,200 months.

Frequently asked questions

Does debt consolidation always save money?

No. A lower APR can still produce a higher total cost when the new term is longer or fees are substantial. This calculator compares total out-of-pocket amounts and payoff time instead of treating a lower payment as automatic savings.

What is the break-even consolidation APR?

It is the highest modeled APR from 0% to 100% at which the consolidation scenario does not cost more out of pocket than the completed current-debt plan, with term, fees, fee handling, repayment plan, and extra payment held constant.

What is the difference between upfront and financed fees?

Upfront fees are paid separately and do not earn loan interest. Financed fees are added to the original loan principal, so they are repaid through loan payments and accrue interest. The calculator includes either treatment once in total out-of-pocket cost.

How are current debts paid in the model?

Every active debt receives its minimum payment first. The rest of the fixed monthly debt budget goes to the highest-APR balance, with deterministic tie-breaks. Money freed by a payoff rolls to the next debt immediately, including within the same month.

Why can a smaller consolidation payment cost more?

A smaller payment can extend repayment across more months. Interest then accrues for longer, and origination or closing fees add cost, so monthly cash-flow relief and total savings must be evaluated separately.

Will a lender offer the payment shown here?

Not necessarily. Actual offers depend on underwriting, credit history, daily interest methods, lender rules, fee deductions, payment timing, and other contract terms that this fixed-rate monthly model does not include.